January 20, 2020
These have together occasioned mainstream politicians
Yet this clampdown is being used as a basis for a greater exaggeration, made by
Mr Doval, that a majority of Kashmiris supported the abrogation of Article 370
(the Constitutional guarantor of autonomy).But what she tweeted was nowhere as
damaging as the BBC’s reportage of the August 9 demonstration at Soura in
Srinagar, in which around 10,000 participated and many were injured in the
consequent police action to break up the demonstration.
It is easier to go after
a homegrown radical like Ms Rashid and debunk her hyperbole, for doing so helps
the government perpetrate greater exaggerations. But Ms Rashid was not
exaggerating the larger clampdown and crackdown on Kashmiri society. She had
tweeted rumours that the Army had tortured four boys in Shopian in south
Kashmir. No wonder, then, that in an absence of ground reports, rumour passes
for fact among individuals like Ms Rashid. Given the government’s penchant to
tightly control what the supposedly free media covers and publishes, perhaps
this sudden drying up of news reports is a coincidence.
These exaggerations by
the state come in a vacuum created in the last week by the dwindling reportage
on Kashmir in the mainstream print media. Activist Shehla Rashid (Photo: File)
On Wednesday, the Delhi Police filed an FIR against Kashmiri (and one-time JNU)
activist Shehla Rashid on a local lawyer’s complaint against her for sedition.
The Army denied it as baseless. Ms Rashid was guilty of hyperbole as less than a
handful of Kashmiris have died during police action on protests after the August
5 announcement to end Jammu and Kashmir’s autonomy; these have been collateral
deaths, like the Noorabad boy who jumped off a bridge when the crowd he was in
was chased by the forces, or the middle-aged man who died of suffocation when
caught between tear gas canisters shot at Srinagar’s Eidgah. Or the greater
exaggeration that all is ostensibly well because most telephone landlines have
been restored when what matters to 99 per cent of the population is the
continuing suspension of mobile telephony.
Or the torrent of reports and
commentary in the New York Times that is unflattering to New Delhi. As it is,
our diplomats’ hands are full this month preparing for the United Nations
General Assembly on the 27th and the UN Human Rights Commission starting Monday.
It is like the greater exaggeration implied in the statement that not a single
bullet has been fired — pellets have been shot at thousands of protestors, of
whom hundreds have been treated in government hospitals.
These have together
occasioned mainstream politicians in the United Kingdom, the Travel Vacuum Bag United States and
elsewhere in the West to express concern over human rights violations in
Kashmir.. Briefing select domestic and foreign journalists on Saturday, National
Security Adviser Ajit Doval also denied it disingenuously: he said it was not
the Army but the Central Reserve Police Force and the state police that was
maintaining law and order in the Valley.
These exaggerations by the state come
in a vacuum created in the last week by the dwindling reportage on Kashmir in
the mainstream print media. Presumably, neither regime-friendly lawyers nor the
Delhi Police dare file FIRs against international news agencies; the risk is in
the narratives that might spin out of control
Posted by: travelvacuum1 at
02:15 AM
| No Comments
| Add Comment
Post contains 553 words, total size 4 kb.
12kb generated in CPU 0.0054, elapsed 0.0301 seconds.
33 queries taking 0.0262 seconds, 48 records returned.
Powered by Minx 1.1.6c-pink.
33 queries taking 0.0262 seconds, 48 records returned.
Powered by Minx 1.1.6c-pink.